Money Was Embezzled Away Showing Fictitious Work-Days
Translation of “Farji karyadivas chadha kar paisa hadap liya gaya”
By Dayamani Barla
Published in Prabhat City- Aaspaas
Ranchi, Wednesday, 25 April 2007
(Translation by Vidya Jonnalagadda)
Money was embezzled from accounts related to the work done under NREGA 2006-07 in Lungatu Panchayat in Basiya Block of Gumla District (of Jharkhand). This was done by entering extra work-days on the Job Cards of workers (more than the number of days that they actually worked) and then preparing a bogus Master Roll to capture the funds. In the matter of entering phony (extra) work-days on the Job Cards, a Case (No. 25/07) of non-cooperation was registered by Panchyat Sevak (Worker) Devmani Sahoo against the Project President Sachhindra Saay and Secretary Baali Gandhi Minj in the Basiya Police Station.
The Station Superintendent, Haridev Prasad came to Lungatu Pandara Toli on 16 April to investigate this case. During the course of this probe, Mr. Prasad examined the Job Cards of the laborers and the Master Roll for the project related to this case. For this, he questioned the Card-holders, scrutinized their cards, and compared them with the amounts recorded as their ‘wages paid’ in the Master Roll. After his inspection, Mr. Prasad told that the number of days recorded on the Job Cards was more than the number of days the people said that they had worked, and the (extra) wages have been embezzled.
He presented the Cards of six people. He informed us that Daniel Kandulana’s family had put in combined work of 19 days, but the Card shows a total of 48 work-days. Dahlia Uraanv had worked for three days, though the Card records work for 12 days against her name, and 48 days for her family. Similarly, Chamru Cheek Badaik worked for two and a half days, but a total of 24 work-days is shown on his Card, and he received merely 86 rupees as wages. The Card of Yugeshwar Khadiya shows 114 days: noting this Mr. Prasad remarked “Well, it looks like you have been favored, that is why you were given work for more than hundred days!” A member of this family, Sugandh Khadiya retorted that he had not worked for even a single day yet 14 work-days are recorded against his name. Maangu Khadiya worked for thirteen and a half days which was recorded as 34 days. Budhu Toppo worked for two days, which got recorded as 24 days.
After his investigation, the Station Superintendent disclosed that the Card-holders had not put any signatures or thumbprints on any Master Roll, but the Master Roll carrying their names had forged signatures and thumbprints. He added that during his investigation he had uncovered irregularities in many other projects as well.
Several amusing facts came to light during this query. In the Master Roll, a thumbprint was found acknowledging receipt of wages against the name of Daniel Kandulana, whereas a signature was found acknowledging the receipt of a Job Card by Daniel Kandulana, who said that he (always) signs his name. A signature marks the receipt of wages in the Master Roll against the name of Noel Kandulana. When scrutinized, it was found that signature in the Master Roll read Manuel Kandulana. The Card-holders declared in their statements that they had neither signed nor put their thumb prints on any Master Roll. After seeing and hearing these matters, Haridev concluded that all Master Rolls were fakes.
The public is generally apprehensive of the Police and typically tries to avoid interacting with them, but when the Police arrived on 16 April for their inquiry, the entire population of Lungatu Panchayat was present at Pandara Toli with their Job Cards. For our readers’ information, the Police had come to record statements of the Card-holders in connection with the recent reports published in the newspaper Prabhat Khabar of the case of swindling of NREGA project funds. 23 projects were undertaken under the aegis of NREGA in Lungatu Panchayat. Funds have been stolen from each of them. Prabhat Khabar highlighted the irregularities in several of these projects, but in order to conceal the enormous extent of the loot of funds, only one case has been registered regarding irregularities in just one project, that too by a person himself suspected of being involved in this scam. On the basis of this case, the investigating officer wanted to record statements of the Card-holders in connection with just that project, but workers defrauded in other projects also wanted to show their Cards (and give their statements). As the word about this investigation spread, more people arrived with their Cards.
The Card-holders who had worked on other projects compelled the officer to listen to their experiences as well. Mahaveer Badaik came with his Card in his hand and said to Mr. Prasad, “Take this and look, you also observe this. Why have wages been reduced or erased on this Card? Why has this Card been stained? We toil in the sun, why don’t we get our rightful share?”
While comparing the Cards and Master Roll, and recording the statements of the Card-holders, the Police personnel were making remarks like “Oh! They have really eaten a lot of money on your name!” Every Card-holder in that crowd wanted to show their Card but the Police had to record the statements related only to the project named in the case. Hundreds of Card-holders from Jolo, Pantariya and Lungatu were present at the venue.
Original Hindi Publication